Neighborhood Requirements Enforcement Report, First Quarter 2022


At the moment we’re publishing our Neighborhood Requirements Enforcement Report for the primary quarter of 2022. It exhibits how we enforced our insurance policies from January by March of 2022 throughout 14 coverage areas on Fb and 12 on Instagram. We’re additionally sharing a number of different stories in our Transparency Heart together with: 

We’re additionally releasing the findings from EY’s impartial evaluation of our enforcement reporting. Final yr, we requested EY to confirm the metrics of our Neighborhood Requirements Enforcement Report since we don’t imagine we should always grade our personal homework. EY’s evaluation concluded that the calculation of the metrics have been ready primarily based on the desired standards and the metrics are pretty said, in all materials respects. As we continue to grow this report, we will even preserve engaged on methods to ensure that it’s precisely offered and independently verified.

Highlights From the Report

The prevalence of violating content material on Fb and Instagram remained comparatively constant however decreased in a few of our coverage areas from This autumn 2021 to Q1 2022. 

On Fb in Q1 we took motion on:

  • 1.8 billion items of spam content material, which was a rise from 1.2 billion in This autumn 2021, due actions on a small variety of customers making a big quantity of violating posts
  • 21.7 million items of violence and incitement content material, which was a rise from 12.4 million in This autumn 2021, because of the enchancment and growth of our proactive detection expertise.

On Instagram in Q1 we took motion on:

  • 1.8 million items of drug content material, which was a rise from 1.2 million from This autumn 2021, resulting from updates made to our proactive detection applied sciences.

We additionally noticed a rise within the proactive detection charge of bullying and harassment content material from 58.8% in This autumn 2021 to 67% in Q1 2022 because of enchancment and growth of our proactive detection expertise. We additionally continued to see a slight lower in prevalence on Fb from 0.11-0.12% in This autumn 2021 to 0.09% in Q1 2022.

Graphic showing bullying and harassment prevalence during Q1 2022

Refining Our Insurance policies and Enforcement

Over time we’ve invested in constructing expertise to enhance how we are able to detect violating content material. With this progress we’ve identified that we’ll make errors, so it’s been equally necessary alongside the way in which to additionally spend money on refining our insurance policies, our enforcement and the instruments we give to customers.

For instance, we’ve improved our transparency over time to raised inform folks why we took down a publish and we’ve improved the flexibility to attraction and ask us to take one other look. We embrace metrics about appeals on this report. Lately we’ve begun to judge the effectiveness of our penalty system extra deeply, for instance testing the impression of giving folks further warnings earlier than triggering extra extreme penalties for violating our insurance policies.

Final yr we noticed how coverage refinements can make sure that we aren’t over implementing past what we intend. Updates we made to our bullying and harassment coverage higher accounted for language that may be simply misunderstood with out context. Enforcement techniques additionally play a task: we lately started testing new AI expertise that identifies and prevents potential over-enforcement by higher studying from content material that’s appealed and subsequently restored. For instance, the identical phrase that’s an offensive slur within the U.S. can also be a typical British time period for cigarette which might not violate our insurance policies. We’re additionally testing various enhancements to our proactive enforcement, to allow some admins of Teams to raised form group tradition and take context under consideration round what’s and isn’t allowed of their area; or to raised replicate the context wherein folks write feedback between associates, the place generally good-natured banter could possibly be mistaken as violating content material.

Wanting Forward

For a very long time, our work has targeted on measuring and lowering the prevalence of violating content material on our providers. However we’ve labored simply as onerous to enhance the accuracy of our enforcement selections. Whereas prevalence helps us measure what we miss, we’ve additionally been engaged on creating sturdy measurements round errors, which is able to assist us higher perceive the place we act on content material incorrectly. We imagine sharing metrics round each prevalence and errors will present a extra full image of our total enforcement system and assist us enhance, so we’re dedicated to offering this sooner or later.

Lastly, as new rules proceed to roll out across the globe, we’re targeted on the obligations they create for us. So we’re including and refining processes and oversight throughout many areas of our work. It will allow us to make continued progress on social points whereas additionally assembly our regulatory obligations extra successfully.



Supply hyperlink