Xcel Vitality desires to vary the way it powers tens of millions of Colorado properties. How that occurs is determined by these hearings

Colorado regulators will kick off a sequence of hearings Wednesday that would decide how the state’s largest utility generates its vitality within the coming many years — and the way a lot it would contribute to world warming.

Xcel Vitality, which provides electrical energy to 1.5 million individuals throughout Colorado, introduced plans to section out its remaining coal vegetation earlier this 12 months and as a substitute rely extra on pure fuel, renewable vitality, and rising expertise corresponding to hydrogen energy.

The utility’s plans got here because the state, pushed by activists and environmental teams, set a aim to slash its greenhouse fuel emissions by half of its 2005 ranges by the tip of the last decade. Elevated urgency to stop the worst results of human-caused world warming pressured Xcel to shut its coal vegetation before it initially deliberate, together with the Comanche Producing Station, one of many state’s single-largest sources of carbon emissions.

Xcel and different teams, together with town and county of Pueblo, unions and state companies, agreed final month to shut Comanche’s latest coal-fired unit by 2035. The transfer might reduce Xcel’s emissions by practically 90 % this decade — however would probably require further funding to exchange and reduce brief tens of millions in property taxes it was paying to Pueblo. Main environmental teams like Western Useful resource Advocates and Sierra Membership didn’t signal the settlement, saying it didn’t go far or quick sufficient to chop emissions.

The Colorado Public Utilities Fee, a three-member physique appointed by the governor, will preside over the hearings, scheduled by way of Dec. 17. The fee might resolve the destiny of Xcel’s coal vegetation as early as February.

A number of teams are anticipated to testify within the coming days. Right here’s the place they stand:

Xcel Vitality

Xcel, which initiated the settlement discussions, has confronted fixed backlash for its administration of Comanche’s latest coal-fired unit, Comanche 3. Regardless of practically two cumulative years of unplanned shutdowns, the corporate pushed towards closing the plant by 2030. Xcel-Colorado President Alice Jackson stated the corporate wanted extra time for rising applied sciences to develop earlier than they may turn into part of the grid. Jackson stated the settlement balances the wants of the corporate, clients and Pueblo, the place the Comanche plant is positioned.

Environmental teams

Environmental teams and coalitions didn’t help closing Comanche by 2035, stressing the necessity to cease burning fossil fuels as quickly as doable to decelerate the speed of world warming. A Sierra Membership consultant denounced a clause within the settlement that might permit Xcel to personal no less than $626 million of technology from the coal-fired unit’s substitute. Gwen Farnsworth, the managing senior coverage advisor for Western Useful resource Advocates, stated that whereas there have been vital compromises within the settlement, it might lead Xcel to accumulate extra pure fuel assets.


The town and county of Pueblo have expressed frustration that Xcel moved up Comanche’s retirement date, saying they had been anticipating the corporate to pay property taxes by way of 2070. Regardless of efforts to maintain Xcel paying that wanted income — and a flashy ultimatum that it construct a nuclear plant in its stead — the 2 authorities our bodies supported the settlement. Xcel doesn’t present electrical energy to Pueblo; residents have complained about having to bear the brunt of the plant’s air pollution.

Labor teams

A number of unions have joined the settlement, together with the Worldwide Brotherhood of Electrical Employees, the Rocky Mountain Environmental Labor Coalition and the Colorado Constructing and Development Commerce Council. The Worldwide Brotherhood of Electrical Employees had supported Xcel’s earlier plan to shut Comanche by 2040, saying it might be much less abrupt for the plant’s staff. It had instructed state regulators that jobs putting in wind and solar energy tasks had been low-paying and short-term and was one of many few teams that supported Pueblo County’s proposal for a nuclear plant.

State companies

The Colorado Workplace of the Utility Client Advocate, Colorado Vitality Workplace and the Colorado Public Utilities Fee’s personal employees joined the settlement. “We expect that it meets our main targets,” stated Keith Hay, director of coverage for the Colorado Vitality Workplace. “It achieves earlier greenhouse fuel emissions reductions, it achieves extra greenhouse fuel emissions reductions by 2030, however simply as importantly, it gives safety to town and county of Pueblo.”

Commerce teams

Commerce teams are divided on their help of the settlement, even inside the renewable vitality trade. The Colorado Photo voltaic and Storage Affiliation and Photo voltaic Vitality Industries Affiliation joined the settlement; the Colorado Renewable Vitality Society didn’t. A number of vitality organizations additionally didn’t be part of, together with the CORE Electrical Cooperative and Interwest Vitality Alliance. The Colorado Oil and Fuel Affiliation, which represents oil and fuel operators, signed on to the settlement.

Supply hyperlink